Dimensions of the Interaction between Logic and Māturīdism in the Context of the Logic–Kalām Relationship: From the Physician-Logician to the Mutakallim -Logician

Author :  

Year-Number: 2026-16:3
Language : İngilizce
Subject : Mantık
Number of pages: 1115-1127
Mendeley EndNote Alıntı Yap

Abstract

This article aims to examine the relationship between logic and kalām, a topic situated within the broader subject of the relationship between philosophy and kalām, from a different dimension. It is necessary to investigate the relationship between kalām, which seeks to ground and defend what is true and real in matters of belief and creed, and logic, which claims to be a path and method that protects human beings from error in thinking and leads them to the truth. In this context, the study considers it more fitting to first look at the relationship between logic and kalām in general terms, and then to focus on the relationship between Māturīdism and logic, taking into account the stages of its development and the position it occupies within the debates on opposition to logic. To make this relationship more distinct and meaningful, a reading based on the relationship between logic and medicine has been developed. Proceeding from this, it is argued that the kalām-logical tradition developed through a dynamic similar to that of the medical-logical tradition, and the notion of a “kalām-logical tradition” is put forward as a finding of the study. Accordingly, the study discusses the profiles of the physician-logician and the mutakallim-logician and employs these conceptualizations. The kalām-logical tradition is assessed both as a natural and Islamic transformation of the physician-logician tradition, which began with Galen and reached its peak with Ibn Sīnā, and as a mode of construction containing motifs specific to the Islamic intellectual world. In addition, the study addresses the debates on the claim that logic did not develop significantly in the Māturīdī tradition. Moreover, by focusing on two points, namely Imam al-Māturīdī’s references to the views of philosophers in his exegesis and his conspicuous omission of Aristotle’s name, the issue is opened to discussion from two angles, and an effort is made to develop a new perspective.

Keywords

Abstract

This article aims to examine the relationship between logic and kalām, a topic situated within the broader subject of the relationship between philosophy and kalām, from a different dimension. It is necessary to investigate the relationship between kalām, which seeks to ground and defend what is true and real in matters of belief and creed, and logic, which claims to be a path and method that protects human beings from error in thinking and leads them to the truth. In this context, the study considers it more fitting to first look at the relationship between logic and kalām in general terms, and then to focus on the relationship between Māturīdism and logic, taking into account the stages of its development and the position it occupies within the debates on opposition to logic. To make this relationship more distinct and meaningful, a reading based on the relationship between logic and medicine has been developed. Proceeding from this, it is argued that the kalām-logical tradition developed through a dynamic similar to that of the medical-logical tradition, and the notion of a “kalām-logical tradition” is put forward as a finding of the study. Accordingly, the study discusses the profiles of the physician-logician and the mutakallim-logician and employs these conceptualizations. The kalām-logical tradition is assessed both as a natural and Islamic transformation of the physician-logician tradition, which began with Galen and reached its peak with Ibn Sīnā, and as a mode of construction containing motifs specific to the Islamic intellectual world. In addition, the study addresses the debates on the claim that logic did not develop significantly in the Māturīdī tradition. Moreover, by focusing on two points, namely Imam al-Māturīdī’s references to the views of philosophers in his exegesis and his conspicuous omission of Aristotle’s name, the issue is opened to discussion from two angles, and an effort is made to develop a new perspective.

Keywords

Logic, philosophy, kalām, māturīdī, medicine-logic, kalām-logic


                                                                                                                                                                                                        
  • Article Statistics