The problem of objectivity, and more specifically the possibility of attaining objective knowledge in football, has gained renewed prominence with the introduction of the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system. While a number of assumptions exist regarding football fans’ attitudes toward VAR, these have not been examined in sufficient depth within an epistemological framework. Based on semi-structured interviews, this qualitative article contributes to addressing this gap by drawing on conceptual resources from epistemology. It argues that VAR should not be treated simply as a technical reform, but as a phenomenon that must be situated within wider debates about objectivity, evidence, and judgment. The findings reveal that fans’ reflections are more nuanced than is often assumed: not all fans subscribe to a naive empiricist understanding of objectivity, and many doubt that even advanced technology and well-intentioned referees can secure access to objective knowledge.
The problem of objectivity, and more specifically the possibility of attaining objective knowledge in football, has gained renewed prominence with the introduction of the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system. While a number of assumptions exist regarding football fans’ attitudes toward VAR, these have not been examined in sufficient depth within an epistemological framework. Based on semi-structured interviews, this qualitative article contributes to addressing this gap by drawing on conceptual resources from epistemology. It argues that VAR should not be treated simply as a technical reform, but as a phenomenon that must be situated within wider debates about objectivity, evidence, and judgment. The findings reveal that fans’ reflections are more nuanced than is often assumed: not all fans subscribe to a naive empiricist understanding of objectivity, and many doubt that even advanced technology and well-intentioned referees can secure access to objective knowledge.
Epistemology, objectivity, naive empiricism, football, video assistant referee (VAR), Turkish Super League