The problem of fictional character identity -determining when characters across different works should be considered identical- has generated two dominant approaches. Neo-Meinongian theories ground identity in properties attributed to characters within fiction, whereas Creationist theories focus on the conditions of authorial creation. Yet property-based theories produce artificial distinctions between nearly identical characters, while creation-based theories offer vague criteria in practice and restrict the creative process exclusively to authors. This article proposes a two-stage model of fictional character creation that extends creationist accounts by including the reader’s constitutive role. In the first stage, the author establishes the character’s initial narrative configuration. However, this stage is not a closed, static, or merely individual origin: authorial identity and creative agency are socially, historically, and culturally mediated. Reader interpretation and reconstruction therefore constitute a second constitutive stage that continues, transforms, and re-situates this initial construction across different contexts of reception. Each reader recreates fictional characters through a perspective shaped by cultural background, personal experience, and temporal context. This expanded creationist account argues that fictional character identity cannot be reduced to fixed criteria, since it depends on both authorial creation and the dynamic, interpretive engagement of readers across time and cultures. The article concludes that an adequate theory of fictional character identity must account for the historically mediated interaction between authorial construction and reader reception, and that such identity is better understood in terms of this constitutive continuity than as a fixed, universally applicable set of identity conditions.
The problem of fictional character identity -determining when characters across different works should be considered identical- has generated two dominant approaches. Neo-Meinongian theories ground identity in properties attributed to characters within fiction, whereas Creationist theories focus on the conditions of authorial creation. Yet property-based theories produce artificial distinctions between nearly identical characters, while creation-based theories offer vague criteria in practice and restrict the creative process exclusively to authors. This article proposes a two-stage model of fictional character creation that extends creationist accounts by including the reader’s constitutive role. In the first stage, the author establishes the character’s initial narrative configuration. However, this stage is not a closed, static, or merely individual origin: authorial identity and creative agency are socially, historically, and culturally mediated. Reader interpretation and reconstruction therefore constitute a second constitutive stage that continues, transforms, and re-situates this initial construction across different contexts of reception. Each reader recreates fictional characters through a perspective shaped by cultural background, personal experience, and temporal context. This expanded creationist account argues that fictional character identity cannot be reduced to fixed criteria, since it depends on both authorial creation and the dynamic, interpretive engagement of readers across time and cultures. The article concludes that an adequate theory of fictional character identity must account for the historically mediated interaction between authorial construction and reader reception, and that such identity is better understood in terms of this constitutive continuity than as a fixed, universally applicable set of identity conditions.
Fictional characters; identity; creationism/artifactualism; Neo-Meinongianism; reader reception; fiction