This study identifies Auguste Debay (1802–1890) as the previously unrecognized source underlying Ahmed Midhat Efendi’s (1844–1912) Lamarckian views in his 1873 article, “İnsân: Dünyâ’da İnsânın Zuhûru” [Man: The Appearance of Man in the World], published in the journal Dağarcık, which he owned. It also determines the particular work by Debay on which Ahmed Midhat relied and examines the direct and indirect ways in which Ahmed Midhat incorporated Debay’s arguments into the article. Establishing this source allows a clearer distinction between elements that Ahmed Midhat borrowed from Debay and those that constitute his own contributions. Within this framework, the study identifies two original contributions in Ahmed Midhat’s treatment of evolution. The first is his criticism of the hypothesis of the inheritance of acquired characteristics, which he challenges through an example also found in Debay. The second is his formulation of a human taxonomy after considering earlier classifications, including Debay’s. Identifying Debay as the source also shows that Ahmed Midhat’s notion of competition, despite its apparent proximity to Darwinian language, belongs within a Lamarckian framework rather than that of the Darwinian “struggle for existence.” These findings clarify Ahmed Midhat Efendi’s views on evolution. As far as the available evidence shows, his article was the first work in Turkey to refer directly to the theory of evolution.
This study identifies Auguste Debay (1802–1890) as the previously unrecognized source underlying Ahmed Midhat Efendi’s (1844–1912) Lamarckian views in his 1873 article, “İnsân: Dünyâ’da İnsânın Zuhûru” [Man: The Appearance of Man in the World], published in the journal Dağarcık, which he owned. It also determines the particular work by Debay on which Ahmed Midhat relied and examines the direct and indirect ways in which Ahmed Midhat incorporated Debay’s arguments into the article. Establishing this source allows a clearer distinction between elements that Ahmed Midhat borrowed from Debay and those that constitute his own contributions. Within this framework, the study identifies two original contributions in Ahmed Midhat’s treatment of evolution. The first is his criticism of the hypothesis of the inheritance of acquired characteristics, which he challenges through an example also found in Debay. The second is his formulation of a human taxonomy after considering earlier classifications, including Debay’s. Identifying Debay as the source also shows that Ahmed Midhat’s notion of competition, despite its apparent proximity to Darwinian language, belongs within a Lamarckian framework rather than that of the Darwinian “struggle for existence.” These findings clarify Ahmed Midhat Efendi’s views on evolution. As far as the available evidence shows, his article was the first work in Turkey to refer directly to the theory of evolution.
Ahmed Midhat; Auguste Debay; Lamarckism; Darwinism; theory of evolution; Ottoman history of science